Challenging the green machine : Rejoinder to Schwartzman
We respond to David Schwartzman’s critique of our paper. We argue that his“solar communism,” his approach to the question of energy return on energyinvestment (EROI), and his critique of Georgescu-Roegen’s fourth law ofthermodynamics situate him as a left ecomodernist, albeit with sympathy fordegrowth. Schwartzman’s take on these issues illustrates how the ontologicalseparation of human ingenuity